I remember when homosexuality was considered a mental
illness by the psychiatric community. Then it was dropped from the roster and a
short time later they recognized homophobia as the problem. They literally
turned on themselves. Not surprising. The psychiatric community has never
entirely had their shit together. And how could they?
The one thing the human brain finds most intolerable to
contemplate is the human brain. What’s going on there? Well for one thing we
have this whole consciousness thing messing everything up. Consciousness most
clearly does not understand itself. We suffer constant illusions that
consciousness is responsible for everything we do and it doesn’t take much
effort (much courage though, perhaps) to detect the falseness of this feeling. Human
feelings are almost always misleading, if not always. When we try to be mindful
we discover that the very vast majority of what we do is without any conscious
participation at all. Furthermore, close self-observation reveals constant
evidence that the thoughts that we’re aware of do not actually seem to have
much control at all over the things we do or the choices we make.
The psych community has very little explanations for all
this, and how can they? The neuroscience community is still working largely
with theories regarding the brain, rather than fact.
What the psych community does seem to be good at though, is
making observations and grouping together generalizations about things and
labeling everything with their labels so that they can talk among themselves
and write reports and give professional advice that is all full of these labels
and thus they sound like they know something. Then when it comes to using the
knowledge they are presumed to have due to all these label references, to actually
solve problems, the solutions become very vague: psychiatric counselling. Which
tends to go on forever without problems actually being solved and while much
money changes hands all the while.
Looking at the history of changes to psychiatric dogma is disappointing. Rather than leading trends in any way, they simply follow
them. The psych community suffers from the cultural superstitions of the day
just like all the masses of ordinary people.
Of course, when you’re smack in the middle of any given
culture, one doesn’t realize how much superstition you’re prey to, because
everyone around you is also crippled by an evolutionary-infantile consciousness
and supports the same illusions.
Currently we are still riddled with sexual superstition. It’s
absolutely ubiquitous. I can think of only one person I know – so far at
least – who I can talk about sex with, in a completely logical way, while the other
9000 or so people I’ve met – are entirely hopeless as far as I can tell. I probably could have said
two people if I’d met Kinsey.
The psych community is right in there with the masses. And
because of all the superstition they’re in bed with, they can’t do the research
they would need in order to become enlightened. Because the research itself
would be deemed sinful – or whatever any given person would say to describe the
product of their hang-ups and confusion.
One day, I’m sure, all sexual predilections will be
discovered to be vastly more common than previously assumed, within the realm
of normal, and free of the mental illness label.
Enter the pedophile. Or more specifically – the sex offender.
What do we do with them?
For now, it doesn’t really matter whether we classify sexual
attraction to children as a mental illness or not. Because sexual
interaction across generations is problematic either way. As long as kids are
at risk of psychological suffering – whether from perceived victimization or
perceived perversity on their own part, and whether the causality stems from
the incident or from the social stigma and a child’s own lack of mental
constitution, sexual interaction between generations is obviously – within this
culture – a very bad idea.
So the courts have to deal with child sex offenders and this
is really tough, because with nowhere else to turn, they put their trust in the
psych community and then receive the flawed information and flawed
recommendations from a not-very-scientific science that doesn’t like to admit
how much they don’t know.
Because we choose to call pedophilia a disease, or at least
think of it in those kind of terms, we’re stuck with the perception that prison
cannot cure them, but we can’t jail them forever, so what the heck do we do?
Between probation, parole, Long-Term Observation orders and
other court-ordered restrictions including the lifetime 161 order which bans prior sex offenders from playgrounds and similar places permanently, we keep a
real close eye on them and hope for the best.
So let’s take a person like Howie.
Howie is a slow child. He has obvious learning disabilities.
And if I may penetrate the illusion of childhood innocence for a moment, Howie
is constantly victimized. He is mocked and bullied every day by his peers
because he is slow. But Howie understands the wicked underbelly of childhood.
There are no police for children. There is no one to protect a child from
another ill-minded child, or gang of them. Life rarely ever works that way.
Howie simultaneously worships and despises his tormentors.
He knows so very well their superiority and their cruelty. He wants to be them,
and he wants to kill them. He reluctantly admires their physicality. His
childish fantasies about their bodies mingle with his fantasies of strangling
them.
For reasons that we don’t understand and that the psych
community doesn’t understand despite a myriad of labels that they will assign
to all of these ideas, Howie grows up without losing these fantasies. The scars
of his powerlessness never heal.
Growing up, he loves horses. Hardly surprising given their
gentleness, which Howie has sorely lacked, and also given the horse’s masculine body structure.
Their extraordinary popularity with pubescent girls invites fairly obvious
theories of psycho-sexual origin.
Howie also loves demolition derbies. Something about the
power granted by the automobile and the aggression and destruction appeals to
the boy who had been so defenseless and afraid to lash out against his
aggressors except in fantasy.
He grows up with his slower-than-average mind and the scars
remain and the fantasies remain, as do his penchants for horses and cars. And
then one day he finds himself in the company of a boy child who reminds him of
all the boy children who haunted him through his formative years. But Howie is
big now; a young adult. He has nothing to fear from this boy. He treats the boy
with gentleness, experimenting with that which he was deprived. And then he
experiments with the violence. He wraps a towel around the boy’s neck and
squeezes until the terrified boy loses consciousness. Then he experiments
further. He removes the boy’s clothes to see his body, and takes pictures so
that he may relive this experience later in his imagination.
The experience is satisfying to Howie. He knows it’s wrong.
He wants not to do it again but he can’t always control his impulses and it
happens again. A habit has been formed.
Howie is captured by police. He’s tried, convicted, serves
time and is eventually released under close observation. He appears to
cooperate with all his conditions, restrictions and treatments. But he never
loses the desires. With no skills for making friends and no capacity for
generating the normal rewards that people take satisfaction in, he spends the
great bulk of his adult life offending, doing time, breaching conditions,
flirting with re-offences and doing more time.
He is in his early 60’s when he finally makes it through a
sentence and a long probation without breaching conditions in
any way. He has earned just a little bit of freedom. He is restricted by the
lifetime 161 order and by a two-year 810 supervisory order which further limits
his mobility but at least he can leave his bedroom at the group home once in a
while without bringing down the wrath of his former probation officer or of his
acting-therapist; a man named Digger.
The psychologist, Rosie, severely limited by that lack of
understanding availed in her field, doesn’t know what to do about Howie and so
doesn’t really do anything with him. She simply declares that Howie has an
incurable sexual pathology and there is no question as to whether he might
re-offend again, but that it is only a matter of when.
First surprising flaw in the system: As a court-appointed
psychologist (the 810 orders Howie to be amenable to treatment by this specific
professional), she suffers no limitations on how the treatment is carried out
or even by whom. So she declines to treat him at all for his crippling anxiety
or communication problems, and instead farms him out to her husband Digger; a
man without medical qualifications of any imagining who is instructed to
interrogate Howie at weekly sessions in order to scare him into confessing
whatever he has been up to.
So the taxpayer foots the bill for treatment which
constitutes an absent psychologist’s half-wit husband grilling the so-called
patient and ritually calling him a liar and acerbating Howie’s anxiety and
communication problems and scaring him into spending more time in his bedroom
where there’s little else to do but fantasize about the sexual victimization of
little boys and staring out his window at the neighborhood children and those
walking to or from school several times a day.
Second surprising flaw in the system: These supervisory
orders are shockingly ambiguous. Lawyers normally write in an almost baffling
legalese in order to effectively facilitate law by being profoundly specific, a
communication style which the masses are not accustomed to. But these
orders are clearly designed with the opposite intent. The language is dull and
attempts at interpretation can go wildly different ways. Multiple offenders
with the same orders can engage in the same activity and some will be
interpreted by police, judges and/or therapists (genuine or otherwise) as
perfectly lawful while others will be jailed for interpreted breaches.
The boon of this system is that judges, lawyers, police and
the psyche community can, in the absence of reliable intelligence concerning
pedophilia as a guide, just trust their
feelings and collude under the umbrella of ambiguity to interpret documents
inconsistently in order to put those behind bars whom they feel they want to.
Likely this system has saved some children from
victimization, as well as jailed some former offenders needlessly and for no legitimate
reason.
A volunteer group works with Howie. Statistically, one in
seven child sex offenders re-offends. Among those who receive aid from the
volunteer group, only one in fifty re-offend.
Enter Randle.
Randle is a new volunteer who is introduced to Howie and like
other volunteers before him, is disarmed by Howie’s capacity for openness. This
elderly man is branded a liar on a weekly basis, yet when away from his current
oppressor, has a child-like way of opening up in an unguarded fashion; a very
likable quality observed less and less in this 21st century megalo-materialist
society.
Randle is a little different. He knows how much feelings
can’t be trusted, like in the rare brief moments when he thinks of Howie as a
monster. He knows how illusory consciousness is; how infantile and unreliable
this exciting brand-new development in evolution is. He knows a few things
about the psych community and about the criminal justice community and due to
his job in corrections he knows a lot of sex offenders.
He knows that people are worth more than their deeds. He
knows that the past is the past and people are capable of great change. He has
experienced great change himself (in completely different forms). He knows that
Howie needs to experience other rewards than the perceived rewards that
bringing fantasy to fruition might bring. He knows that Howie needs to replace
bad habits with useful, rewarding habits and that this cannot be done, hiding
in his little institutional bedroom.
Howie is acutely aware of his own age. He is utterly
convinced that any mistake at all, a re-offence or just a breach, will result
in him going back to prison for the rest of his life. Howie, for the first time
in his long grueling life, has a friend that he can trust. That is one reward
that is making a difference. And the things that Howie and Randle do together
manifest more rewards. After horses and race cars, Howie loves dogs and he
loves coffee. And he likes solving word-search puzzles. The other kinds of
puzzles are too difficult.
With Randle he gets out of his bedroom often. They go to Tim
Hortons and drink a lot of coffee. Sometimes Randle has work to get done on his
laptop so Howie solves his puzzles. Randle always keeps a few books of them on
hand. Sometimes a kid will come in and sit near them and so Randle and Howie
leave and sit in the car instead. They visit with the dogs who belong to
Randle’s friend. Howie loves them and they love him. They stick to him like
glue and Howie enjoys fussing with them all day while Randle does his work
nearby.
They take drives in the country. They get ice cream at the
dairy during school hours. They go down by the lift bridge, but away from
parks, and watch the big laker liners come in. One time a family with kids is
in the area and so they leave, and decide just to come during school hours.
They take the dogs to an off-leash area during school hours;
not that kids go to off-leash areas anyway. Kids are not permitted
unaccompanied by adults, and families with dogs have little need for off-leash
zones with their inherent risks. Parents don’t want their kids exposed to those
same risks that bring about the restrictions.
They go swimming at the adult swim during school hours,
doubly isolated from any chance of glimpsing a child whatsoever.
They go to antique stores and occasionally to restaurants
and always Randle is on the lookout for kids. It’s strange though, this
constant vigilance. What does it achieve? It has never been Howie’s habit to
abduct a child; only to molest one who was trusted to his care. The idea that
he will sneak off with a child under Howie’s nose is purely preposterous.
Ah, but triggers. The psych community has found a word that
makes for a great label. Pedophiles are like loaded guns. They must be kept
away from triggers. They must not find themselves looking at kids.
Of course there’s a huge inconsistency here, isn’t there?
Howie’s been placed in a group home third-floor bedroom with
a window overlooking a street where plenty of kids live and play.
His interrogator, Digger, the half-wit husband, rents a
modest office space across the street from a school and schedules Howie to
arrive just when hoards of kids are walking to and from the school on their
lunch break.
Driving down the street to go for coffee there are kids on
the sidewalks. In fact there are probably 100,000 kids living in the same city
where Howie lives and there is simply no way to avoid them. And of course, kids
pop in and out of coffee shops with consistent regularity.
So how this trigger-avoidance deal is intended to work is
quite the mystery. Former rapists of adult women are not expected to go through life without glimpsing women. Maybe no one really gets it. Maybe it’s just a matter of the
creep factor. Maybe we just trust the little feeling that says – we don’t want
pedophiles in the same places as kids would have fun in. Because that’s just
creepy. We want to see our kids having fun in the illusory absence of
pedophiles. And we don’t want sex offenders to glean any of the magic that the
rest of us can, watching kids just be kids. We’ll take that away from them just
for the hell of it – because they’re monsters and we should never stop finding
ways to make them suffer.
Of course Randle thinks about how Howie suffered all through
his childhood and what tragedies stemmed from all that. Randle does not suspect
that suffering makes the world a safer place.
But Digger needs to earn a living off the tax-payers, or at
least help his wife to do so. So he must posture himself as being useful. He
must be perceived to be accomplishing something. And sounding the alarm for transgressions
or imaginary transgressions is the only thing he knows how to do or else has
the mandate to do, so he must keep interpreting transgressions, one way or the
other. So he sounds the alarm about the off-leash area where kids never go and
he sounds the alarm about the swimming pool where kids never go during adult
swim time while they are in school. And he sounds the alarm because Randle and
Howie played mini-golf on a quiet evening and came within sight of a single
child who was in no danger of any kind and who was not the relevant age/gender
combination to trigger Howie in the slightest.
So Digger is motivated by money (who can blame him?) and
Detective Dan is motivated by having too much work to do (who can blame him?)
and doesn’t want to have to go check out more locations than he has to, and so
together, under their cozy umbrella of ambiguity, they scare Howie away from
the places he wants to go; mostly places where children are never present. And
sometimes they outright cheat and say, “You can’t go there!” and leave Howie to
think they’re respecting the law instead of their personal interests.
And so things that Howie is allowed to do, in order to
generate healthy rewards, according to the charter of rights and freedoms, with
a reasonable interpretation of his court orders, are in effect forbidden him on
a whim. Of course, he could go if he chose to and as his rights allow, and he
could not be put in jail, but then he would piss off the wrong people. Digger
and Detective Dan have the option to apply to the court for a renewal of the
810 order upon its expiry in another year; something Howie prays won’t happen
if he is deemed “good.”
Randle would far prefer that the 810 order become permanent,
but interpreted with intelligence, wisdom and logic.
Randle is very concerned that Howie is going to spend what’s
left of his life waiting for freedom that will never come, and remain in a
fragile place with regards to community safety, instead of making real
progress.
Randle is concerned that the system seems flawed, corrupted
and based on junk psychology and should be challenged. Randle also knows that
staying quiet about it could eventually make his volunteer work very easy and
simple, when Tim Hortons becomes the only place at all that Howie is allowed to
go, not because Tim Hortons is a child-free place. No. Because Tim Hortons is a
soulless pit of an institution where no magic will ever happen; certainly no
kid magic.
Every cup tells a story.